I had piano lessons for eight years as a child, and I hated them. What I wanted was to dance. I watched every dance performance I could get to and dreamed of being a professional dancer, and then I went back to the piano: disciplined, rigid, and disconnected from anything I felt.

When I grew up, I did not let myself dance at all. The reasoning sounded like common sense. What is the point? I would never dance well. It was too late. I would never be a performer. My goal-oriented mind could not picture doing something purely for enjoyment and never being good at it.

So I did not begin, and that suited my inner critic perfectly. It never had to watch me dance badly. It just made sure I did not start.

I started properly at forty. I did not want to. I resisted, I could not see the point, and when I finally got onto a dance floor I felt silly, stiff and ashamed. I kept going anyway. At forty-five, pole dancing, I went upside down for the first time.

Dance and depression: what the research says

I have called dancing my medicine. When my energy is heavy or stuck, music moves what words cannot.

When a big Australian study came out in 2024, I shared the headline version of it: dancing helps your mood more than yoga, running or strength training. That is not quite what it found. Noetel and colleagues, writing in the BMJ, pooled more than two hundred randomised trials of exercise for depression. Dance produced some of the largest drops in depression of any kind of exercise. It was also one of the least studied, a handful of small trials, and the authors said that was why they could not recommend it more strongly. Walking or jogging, yoga and strength training had the firmer evidence.

So dance looks promising, and that is as far as the evidence goes. Mood turned out to be the smallest part of what dancing did to me.

The patterns I took to therapy showed up on the dance floor

For a few years now I have practised contact improvisation in Bali, a partner dance built entirely on reading another person's weight and responding to it. It has no set steps, and in movement there is nowhere to hide.

Everything I had worked through in years of therapy was there, without a word spoken: how I respond to closeness, to pressure, to silence. The same pains I thought I had finished with. The same coping. It is fascinating to observe, and harder to work through.

Available without fully arriving

My teacher saw it before I had named it: I make myself available without fully arriving.

I know where it comes from. I grew up reading my parents' moods before my own, and in close relationships I still feel what the other person feels before I feel what I feel. In a therapy session I could describe that for an hour and sound very insightful. In a dance built on shared weight, my partner simply feels that I am not all the way there.

Contact improvisation also gave me touch, and I had no idea how much my wellbeing depended on it until I went back to Singapore from Bali and had almost none. An adult life can contain very little ordinary, unhurried, non-sexual touch. On the dance floor in Bali it is just part of the practice.

When a racing heart feels like danger

As a child I knew my father's mood from the sound of his key in the door. I could tell, before he came in, whether yelling and throwing objects would follow. My body was a radar system, not a place of pleasure.

In my twenties I avoided the gym because a fast heartbeat felt threatening. I thought something was wrong with my heart. Only later, studying trauma, did I start to wonder whether the sensation itself had been paired with danger. There was my mother too. My clearest memory of her is her absence in front of a television, and a daughter who was too alive, too expressive, too much, might have overwhelmed her. Turning myself down kept me close to her.

Dancing asks my body for exactly the sensations it learned to treat as warnings: a racing heart, fast breath, heat, being seen. Even now, when I move toward that kind of aliveness, resistance comes up first.

One trial gives me some hope here. Smits and colleagues, in Depression and Anxiety in 2008, worked with people who were frightened of their own body's sensations of arousal. Two weeks of exercise reduced that fear much more than waiting did, and their anxious and low mood improved along with it. The study was small, and it tested exercise in general, not dance. But it matches what I find in myself: the body learns from the sensation, felt again and again with nothing bad following, more than from any explanation I give it. I am still in that work.

Dancing in front of strangers

At Burning Man this year I sat in the dust watching younger women dance the way I have wanted to dance my whole life. There were so many talented people, and the old sentence came right on time: something is wrong with me. Under it was grief, for the dancer I wanted to be all my life and never became.

Then I danced in my camp's performance. Standing up in front of people to do it meant far more to me than the few minutes it lasted. My fear of people was right there. The small person in me was very clear about how little she trusts, and I had to let my protectors go one at a time, as far as I could.

The desert also showed me how rarely I let myself choose anything fully. A person, a direction, a country. I keep one foot outside, and I have always called that freedom. The dance was small. I chose it completely for a few minutes, with my whole body, in front of strangers, and I was still there afterwards.

I will not become the dancer I dreamed about at the piano, and that grief came home from the desert with me. I am in menopause now, and I still ask myself whether it is okay, at my age, to put sparkles on my face and dance. The question has not gone, it just no longer decides whether I go.

Is there something you stopped, or never started, because you would never be good at it?

References

Noetel, M., Sanders, T., Gallardo-Gómez, D., Taylor, P., del Pozo Cruz, B., van den Hoek, D., Smith, J. J., Mahoney, J., Spathis, J., Moresi, M., Pagano, R., Pagano, L., Vasconcellos, R., Arnott, H., Varley, B., Parker, P., Biddle, S., & Lonsdale, C. (2024). Effect of exercise for depression: Systematic review and network meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials. BMJ, 384, e075847. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj-2023-075847

Smits, J. A. J., Berry, A. C., Rosenfield, D., Powers, M. B., Behar, E., & Otto, M. W. (2008). Reducing anxiety sensitivity with exercise. Depression and Anxiety, 25(8), 689-699. https://doi.org/10.1002/da.20411

If this speaks to you, subscribe to my mailing list.

Subscribe