It is two in the morning and your brain will not turn off. You are replaying a conversation from work and rehearsing one you have not had yet. You know this pattern well enough to name it, maybe well enough to explain where it comes from. Naming it has not made it stop. You have friends, you keep a journal, you have read the good books, some of them twice. And somewhere around half past two the question arrives: do I actually need therapy, or should I be able to sort this out myself?

The second half of that question tends to be the louder one. Should be able to. It turns the whole decision into a test of whether you are struggling enough to deserve help, measured against someone who has it worse. Nobody passes that test, because someone always has it worse. You don't need a diagnosis. You need a reason that matters to you.

Signs you might need therapy

None of these is a diagnosis. Any one of them is a reasonable reason to book a first conversation.

When you might not need therapy, or not yet

I think about it the way I think about exercise. Everyone needs to move, and plenty of people train well on their own. They know their body, they have worked with a trainer before, they know what they need and can get themselves out of the door. Psychological health works in a similar way. If you get on with yourself and the people close to you without the same fights and hurts coming back again and again, and fear is not steering the big decisions, then time with people you love, a journal and good books may be exactly enough.

Therapy is also not always the right next step, even when you are struggling. If what is in front of you is a debt, a lease, a sick parent or three weeks of broken sleep, you may need practical help or rest first, and a therapist cannot supply either. If you are going because someone else wants you to, say so in the first session, because therapy done for another person tends to stall. And if what you want is someone to confirm that the other person is the problem, a good therapist will disappoint you, usually around the third session.

Timing matters too. Going into old trauma in the middle of a divorce, a move or a new job can be too much at once. A careful therapist will often start with steadiness in the present and only then go near the past.

What therapy actually is, and what it is not

A friend takes your side. A therapist takes the side of your whole life, including the parts of you that keep making the same choice.

In practice therapy is a relationship with a structure. You meet regularly, usually weekly or fortnightly at the start. Over the first sessions you and your therapist build a formulation together: a working map of how your history, your body and your current life fit together to keep the pattern going. The map is what turns three apparently separate problems, the insomnia, the argument with your sister and the overworking, into one story that can be worked with.

Then the work becomes less about understanding and more about experience. Feeling something in a session that you have spent years managing. Saying a sentence you have never said out loud and noticing what happens in your chest as you say it. Trying something new with a person who will not punish you for it. I knew the frameworks and the language long before any of it changed me. Knowing them was not the same as processing.

It is not a straight line either. Sometimes you will feel more before you feel better. It is easy to read that as therapy failing, when often it means something you kept at arm's length is now close enough to work with.

Research on what makes therapy work keeps returning to the relationship. Flückiger and colleagues pooled nearly three hundred studies and found a consistent link between the strength of the working relationship and how well therapy went. The link held across very different types of therapy, across countries, and for online therapy as well as face-to-face. These studies show a link rather than proof of cause, and the link fits something I have believed for most of my working life: what heals people is not technique alone, but the quality of the nervous system they sit across from.

How to choose a therapist

Start with training and registration. In Australia you can look up any psychologist on the public AHPRA register. In other countries the rules differ, and titles like counsellor, therapist or coach can mean very different levels of training, so ask directly: what is your training, who are you registered with, and who supervises your work?

Then look at fit. After two or three sessions, ask yourself whether you can say the hard sentence with this person. Whether you can tell them they got something wrong, and what happens when you do. Whether you leave feeling understood and also a little stretched. Someone can be an excellent therapist and still be the wrong one for you, and changing therapists is allowed.

What you want from therapy matters as well. Swift and colleagues reviewed more than fifty studies and found that when people received the kind of therapy they preferred, fewer of them dropped out and their outcomes were somewhat better. If you know you want to work with the body, or you want structure and practice between sessions, or you want to understand your childhood, say so at the start.

The names you are likely to meet

Most experienced therapists draw on more than one of these. I trained in several, and which one I use depends on the person and what they bring.

What the first therapy session is like

Most first sessions are more questions than relief. Your therapist will ask what brings you, what you want to be different, and a fair amount about your history: family, relationships, health, what has helped before and what has not. It can feel strange to tell your life story to someone you met fifty minutes ago. Some people leave lighter. Some leave tired or a little raw and need a slow evening.

Over the first few sessions you should get a sense of how your therapist understands what is going on, and some idea of a plan. If you do not, ask. A good therapist will tell you how they are thinking and will want you shaping the plan with them. In my own work the aim from the start is for you to need me less over time, and to carry what we build into the rest of your life.

If you are curious how I work, I offer a free introductory call before anything is booked, to see whether we are a fit. You can read about it on my individual therapy page.

Therapy or coaching?

Coaching can be useful when you know where you want to go and need structure, accountability and someone in your corner. Therapy is for when the obstacle is you, or rather the parts of your history that keep steering. If the same pattern shows up in your work, your relationships and your body, and especially if there is trauma underneath it, you need someone trained to work with the history as well as the goal. I wrote more about the difference, and about the transformation coaching that has grown up around wellness communities in places like Bali, in coaching vs psychology.

Why it is so hard to tell from the inside

When I started my own therapy, I did not go for trauma. I went because of social anxiety and feeling overwhelmed by life. I believed I was evil, disgusting, harmful to people just by being present. I did not think my thoughts were distorted. They were simply my reality.

It took many years of work, my own therapy, personal EMDR and schema work, before I understood that my childhood had been unpredictable and frightening, and that I had taken what my parents told me about who I was and made it into fact. If I had waited until I was sure I needed help, I would not have gone. Those beliefs would never have appeared on a list of reasons, because to me they were simply true.

So if you are awake at two in the morning asking the question, you do not have to settle first whether you are struggling enough. You can book one conversation and find out what it is like to say the two-in-the-morning thoughts out loud, in daylight, to someone whose job is to help you with them.

References

Flückiger, C., Del Re, A. C., Wampold, B. E., & Horvath, A. O. (2018). The alliance in adult psychotherapy: A meta-analytic synthesis. Psychotherapy, 55(4), 316-340. https://doi.org/10.1037/pst0000172

Swift, J. K., Callahan, J. L., Cooper, M., & Parkin, S. R. (2018). The impact of accommodating client preference in psychotherapy: A meta-analysis. Journal of Clinical Psychology, 74(11), 1924-1937. https://doi.org/10.1002/jclp.22680

If this speaks to you, subscribe to my mailing list.

Subscribe