At my keynote in Singapore in September I told a hall full of people that they would clap at the end, and that I would come off the stage and go straight to the part I got wrong. I was describing a habit. I can give a talk that goes well, hear the applause, and walk off already replaying the one sentence I fumbled. Everything else that happened in that hour goes into storage. The fumbled sentence comes home with me, and I rehearse the better version of it for days, as if anyone were still listening.

I have more than fifteen years of clinical work behind me and I know exactly what this is. Knowing has never stopped it. So this is my best account of why the mind gets stuck in negative thinking, from both chairs: the one I sit in as a psychologist, and the one I sit in when the sentence starts playing again.

Why your mind goes to the negative first

The first part is ordinary. A mind notices bad information faster and holds on to it longer than good. Baumeister and colleagues reviewed the evidence across a huge range of psychology, from close relationships to feedback to the way we learn, and concluded that bad is stronger than good almost everywhere they looked. Bad feedback has more impact than good feedback, and bad information is processed more thoroughly. They could find hardly any exceptions.

So one wrong sentence outweighing forty minutes of right ones is the brain doing what brains do. That explains why I notice the sentence. Why I am still saying it to myself in the shower two days later, long after any lesson in it has been learned, needs a different explanation.

Why replaying a mistake feels like solving it

Rumination presents itself as work. If I go over it once more, I will understand what went wrong, and it will not happen again. It has the feel of diligence, which is exactly why capable women are so good at it.

Lyubomirsky and Nolen-Hoeksema tested what that diligence produces. People who were already low in mood were asked either to ruminate on their feelings and on themselves, or to distract themselves with something neutral. The ruminators read everyday situations more negatively, were more pessimistic about good events in their future, and came up with worse solutions to real problems between people. The low-mood participants who had been distracted solved problems as well as people who were not low at all.

The loop makes the thinking worse at the one job it claims to be doing. Three more passes through the fumbled sentence do not make me a better speaker. They build a more convincing case that I am not one.

I have written separately about overthinking as a reinforcement trap, where you worry, nothing bad happens, and the mind credits the worrying. Negative thinking about yourself has its own engine underneath, and it runs on feeling as much as on thought.

Staying in your head so you do not have to feel

It is much easier to be in the head than in the body, feeling fear or guilt or shame. Thinking at least looks like action. Feeling looks like doing nothing, and it hurts more.

A small study from 1990 fits this closely, and it happens to be about public speaking. Borkovec and Hu worked with people who were anxious about giving speeches and asked them to picture a frightening speaking scene again and again. Before each picture, some of them relaxed, some thought about something neutral, and some worried. The worriers' hearts reacted least to the feared scene, yet they reported more fear than the neutral group. The authors' reading was that worry may block the emotional processing of fear, and so keep the fear intact.

When I replay the sentence, I am in words. What I am not doing is feeling what it does to me to be seen by a hall full of people, which is older and more physical than embarrassment. Most of my life visibility felt risky. The replay is safer than that. It hands me a problem to work on in place of a feeling to sit through, and the fear underneath stays exactly where it was, ready for the next stage.

Why negative thoughts about yourself are so hard to let go

The loop also holds because of what it promises. Every replay of the sentence ends in the same verdict: I got it wrong, I should have prepared better, the fault is mine. That verdict is painful, and it carries an odd comfort. If the fault is mine, I can fix it. Next time I will be more careful, more prepared, more perfect, and then it will not happen.

I said at the keynote that turning on yourself is a defence that does not look like a defence. It looks like standards and taking responsibility, and most high-functioning women have been rewarded for it their whole lives. The voice that replays your mistakes speaks like a coach. Mine speaks in my mother's grammar. I grew up with put-downs and blame, and a child in that position has very little power. Deciding that she is the problem gives her some. If I am to blame, there is something I can do.

That is my clinical reading as much as my personal one. For a lot of women, endlessly replaying what they got wrong is easier to live with than the helplessness underneath it. The thinking is negative, and it is also a bid for control. Offering it a kinder thought misses the point, because the kinder thought asks the mind to give up the only lever it believes it has.

If the voice in your own loop has a familiar accent, my free inner critic guide starts with two days of simply noticing when it speaks and what it says.

What helps when you are stuck in negative thinking

Arguing back rarely works, for the reasons above. What helps starts earlier, at the moment the sentence begins playing again. Catch it there, before any analysis, and recognise it as the replay rather than as new information about you.

Then ask the question the loop is designed to avoid: if I stopped replaying this right now, what would I have to feel instead? Often the answer is a few seconds of something raw. Exposure, shame, the old fear of being too visible. Those seconds are hard, and they pass faster than the loop does.

Distraction has a bad name in therapy circles, yet in the Lyubomirsky study a short spell of neutral distraction put low-mood people back on their feet. A walk, cooking, anything that needs your hands can break a loop open. It becomes avoidance when it is the only move you ever make.

The longer work is learning to hear the thought without obeying it, which ACT calls defusion. I have written about how to practise that in a separate piece on how to unhook from your thoughts.

The next time I walk off a stage, the sentence will probably be waiting for me. What I am practising is the moment it starts: noticing it start, and staying for a few seconds with the woman who just stood up in front of all those people and let herself be seen, before I send her back to rehearse.

References

Baumeister, R. F., Bratslavsky, E., Finkenauer, C., & Vohs, K. D. (2001). Bad is stronger than good. Review of General Psychology, 5(4), 323-370. https://doi.org/10.1037/1089-2680.5.4.323

Borkovec, T. D., & Hu, S. (1990). The effect of worry on cardiovascular response to phobic imagery. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 28(1), 69-73. https://doi.org/10.1016/0005-7967(90)90056-O

Lyubomirsky, S., & Nolen-Hoeksema, S. (1995). Effects of self-focused rumination on negative thinking and interpersonal problem solving. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 69(1), 176-190. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.69.1.176

If this speaks to you, subscribe to my mailing list.

Subscribe